Vision for Britain 6 : Public investment and High Tech

This essay completes the 10 strategies of the Vision, with Strategies 9 and 10. The next essay will be a reminder of the opportunities the Vision offers and the outcomes that can be achieved with commitment and effort over say 20 years.

But first, a reminder once again of the 10 strategies :

1    Economic modelling of this proposed programme

2    A 20 year programme of redeploying wasted resources

3    Responding to climate change and tackling plastics

4    Establish a North/South divide and Southern restraint policy

5    Private sector investment

6    A 20 year programme of raising wages and incomes

7    A 20 year programme of reducing benefits

8    A 20 year programme to create a society where food and housing are paid from the income of each person and family, and pensions and social care in old age are paid from their savings

9    Public sector investment and day to day spending

10  Continuing to promote high tech etc

Strategy 9 Public sector investment and day to day spending

Defence

Because defence spending is such a big issue, I will devote a few words to it.

My first point is that in the short term, spending a lot is quite unnecessary, (say up till 2030 when Russia is scheduled to attack us, so I gather Putin tells us). This is because we only have to spend on the army and that’s not hugely expensive.  Here’s why and how.

The Ukraine war is fought by infantry on foot, with computerised drones and cheap missiles, complex command and control systems and a daily upgrading of systems to keep ahead of the enemy. They are supported by supply chains which include more conventional kit such as lorries, trains and air power. Air-fired missiles and drones are also used.

( The Russians, Iranians, Houthi’s, even the Americans, and everyone else except the Ukrainians are allowed to use ballistic missiles.  The Ukrainians aren’t even given enough anti-ballistic missile missiles. If the Ukrainians are not given ballistic missiles to destroy the Russian ballistic missile factories, the war will drag on killing of maiming another million Ukrainians and Russians. Nearly 5 years of war so far. How much more slaughter will Europe and America stand by and watch? )

Meanwhile in Ukraine, tanks and other mobile armoured kit is not used.  They don’t fight each other.  Fighter aircraft aren’t used.  They don’t fight each other.  Ships aren’t used.  They don’t fight each other.  And it’s not as if there’s anywhere safe to park them — poor old Trump: they weren’t safe in the Middle East, and now he can’t even find somewhere safe in leafy Gloucestershire.  And poor old Putin, not even in the Arctic Circle. The trouble is that big bits of kit like the USS carrier driven out of the Red Sea last year by the Houthis, have to be far from the action to be safe—but then they can’t be used.

None of the expensive kit is used.  None of this advanced technology in big kit is used. None of the kit that takes years to design and decades to deliver is used.  None of the kit that costs all the money is used (except ballistic missiles). It’s all vulnerable to drones and cheap missiles—and expensive ones too.

If we had started 2 or 3 years ago, we could have re-equipped and retrained the British army by now.  The only thing we wouldn’t be able to do is to update its technology and skill daily—as a soldier needs to do on the modern battlefield.

The British army needs to repel a Russian advance—that’s its main aim now.  Ukraine has done it for nearly 5 years with little help from us—certainly far too little.  If Russia attacked Europe, it would immediately lose Kaliningrad and control of the Baltic.  Russia would have no world access via the Back Sea, no world access via the Baltic!  And we can also control the North Atlantic.  Russia strategically is completely at our mercy in Europe. Germany lost the First World War largely for this reason.

So our spending should be on re-equipping and retraining the British Army for a Ukraine war.  This can be done quickly and cheaply.

Most UK spending on expensive kit should be halted till the world learns how to use it on today’s battlefields  Then new designs can be created. The aircraft carriers should be mothballed. ( I’m an accountant. I know that can’t be done easily. And the defence industry and the unions want more big spending: for profit and for employment. But it can be done –The Times reported this past week on how much money we urgently found to waste on food trade control on Brexit –this is far bigger and far more important. )

Finally, we should recognise at long last that we, the UK, cannot be, and are not, and never have been, an independent nuclear power.   Originally we were nuclear as allies of the USA, but using their kit.  This equality disappeared with Suez. Now, especially with Trump, we are but lackeys of the USA. 

But also, for 250 years the USA has been isolationist.  The American colonists before that were also isolationist. That’s why they rebelled.  It’s in the blood.  But it’s not surprising: they are 3,000 miles or more from the rest of the world. All the Americas are like that. And we likewise are isolated from them in ways we are not isolated from our continental mass.  It’s geography what does it!   And it’s only Western Culture, the English language and to some extent Spanish and Portuguese, that make things very different.

Besides, US power is waning—and fast under Trump. Trump wants to be King Donald the Dum of the USA, and Emperor with No Clothes of All the Americas.  Even he perhaps, has begun to see he can wield more clout in the Americas than elsewhere. He’s not interested in Europe which he despises and costs him money. Now he’s said he won’t spend on Israel. So Trump is not unusual in wishing to rid the USA of European defence: all US governments are by nature isolationist.

But if we are not part of the US nuclear force, we have a huge problem of cost: we can’t afford our own nuclear deterrent.  So if we want one, then it should be with France and Germany—with our own European weapons system.

And if anyone thinks—they do—that China and India will allow Putin to lob nuclear bombs in our direction, then they have another think coming.  India and China wish to be top nations and to finish bringing 2 billion people out of poverty. Does anyone really think they would allow a local squabble amongst tin-pot European nations to create a nuclear winter?  Emperor Xi and Mughal Modi are clever chaps. Zelensky has reported that Emperor Xi has told Czar Putin, “No Nukes!”—and probably told him more than once.

Britain has to come to terms with reality—the post 1945 reality.  After 81 years of clinging on to past glories, it has not yet fully done so. We are a European power.

(The USA of course, is in its own cloud-cuckoo land, and has the same problem—only it’s not so blindingly obvious yet—not that anyone notices the blindingly obvious—it’s one of the strange things about the blindingly obvious!  It has to be pointed out to people!)

As we, the UK, don’t have the money for anything it seems, (at least we think we don’t), we will never get to 3% on defence. But it won’t matter.  It will save us wasting trillions on out-dated, worthless, hugely expensive kit, which would otherwise start being delivered to our forces in 10 years’ time!

So, in the meantime, let’s halt much of the spending on expensive kit, save £2 or £3 billion for 2 years and re-equip and re-train the entire army.   By then, we might have a better idea as to how to spend money on expensive kit .

The public sector generally

A key part of any national vision is public sector investment and day to day (or annual) spending.  (Capital expenditure and revenue expenditure)  I have no radical ideas other than for defence. But I have a few remarks to make.

Firstly, we must continue the normal range of spending, both long term investment and day to day spending.  Climate change action, and attention to our energy needs are vital.  And so also is infrastructure investment both to drive economic growth and to pursue the regional strategies. As we make the other changes of the previous strategies we will be able to increase public investment on climate change and economic growth.

Training and apprenticeships should no longer just be fashionable.  They require commitment—long-term programmes —and permanent programmes—not ones that will have disappeared yet again after 10 years. We have been learning about Germany’s apprenticeship schemes since the 1880’s.  That’s 150 years ago. But we still haven’t got them.  They simply come and go.

We need to spend more on foreign aid. Our big debt to the rest of the world has to be paid—and it seems the best way to do it is to spend overseas on climate change action. I don’t believe in reparations for past miss-deeds.  Besides, we have two Bengal famines and the Irish Great Hunger to be sorry for, as well as slavery.  The Arabs have slavery.  The Chinese have Tibet and the Yuigurs and 2,000 years of previous persecution of minorities.  Russians also have some terrible crimes against conquered peoples . We all have skeletons in our cupboards.

By all means let us have efficiency in the public sector. But let’s not have the self delusion of savings of 1% per annum or even more, which has led to cuts in services.  Local government spends 30% less than it did in 2010.  Bigger cuts than that, if we go back to Thatcher’s glory days. Does anyone really and seriously think that is efficiency savings?  What efficiency savings have been made in restaurants in the last 20 years? By management consultants in their own offices? By solicitors and accountants like me?  Have they cut their spending by 30% since 2010?  Of course they haven’t—because they provide personal services like schools and the health service do, and a lot of local government.  Savings of 30% or more cannot be made without cutting staff—front line staff, as administration is only 10 or 15% of staff costs anyway.   The developers across our road say we need more planners  at Winchester City Council — but most planners went as efficiency savings some years back. The one working on the development across the road only worked part-time—you could only get her 3 days of the week.  Efficiency savings on planners make life more difficult for developers.

With the changes to public spending that I envisage in the wage and housing strategies, there should be some reduction in expenditure totals. Beyond spending on the strategies above, my inclination would be to put much of any spare cash into health and education.

Strategy 10 Knowledge and High Tech

It is knowledge and technology that has been the main driver of economic growth throughout world history.  It has been dramatic in the last 300 years and still is dramatic.

Yet our national discussion and debate of key issues for Britain today on technology is very restricted.  It is true that we emphasise computing technology generally and A.I in particular.  We talk of science parks at Cambridge, and the South East as far as Bristol, being home to new technology. But it scarcely goes beyond that. Even Covid vaccines are not prominent as super new technology, solely as saving maybe thousands of British lives—which is certainly their main achievement.  But they are a technological triumph.

Nor do we celebrate the NHS as one of the great drivers of technological breakthrough and achievement—just look at the amazing stuff they can do, and which wasn’t possible when I was a lad.  What a triumph of our NHS workers!  Take a bow from me for your great technological prowess, as well as for saving our lives.  Apart from electronics, the NHS is probably the biggest single driver of technological progress in the UK.  It at least equals the transport industry and the defence industry.  And the NHS also drives pharmaceuticals.  I am amazed at our modesty about all this, we public servants.

Even combatting climate change is not rated a high priority because it also produces economic growth.  That is the claim of many people.  Google A.I tells me that the OECD thinks so.  I can’t imagine Chinese electric vehicles production to combat climate change has done anything other than produce vast economic growth–which the west has missed out on.   But if combatting climate change does produce economic growth, and I think we want economic growth—am I correct?—then why are we not doubling down on it?  If it not only saves our lives, but it raises our standard of living, then why don’t we get obsessed by it?  We’d get double value for our bucks! Instead we’re cutting back!

I’m afraid the new administration, with its selection of worthy changes, is little or no better than what has gone before, for a couple of decades or more.  How do devolution, a written constitution, social care, doubts about defence spending, possible tax rises, etc advance economic growth?  Their efficacy in that respect is most obscure.  And some road schemes have been cut.  And reversing Brexit! It’s taken 10 years so far not to do it! A big boost to house building would boost growth—but how is that to be funded, and have we got the wood?  And when? When?

The nation needs a dynamic and compelling strategy for technology —from the government, the private sector, from the City—and not just high tech, and climate change, but technology generally, training, apprenticeships, £ billions of investment.  I can’t write that strategy, or an outline would be here.

© Philip Morgan 2026 Public Policy Conjectures  All rights reserved.

Leave a Reply