In this final part of the Vision for Britain, I summarise the opportunities it presents and the achievements that it could secure for Britain. But before I do that, we need to consider the effect of the Vision on Neo-liberal economics. This consideration is needed because all the political parties today are wedded to Neo-liberal economics, and to its monetary restrictions on the freedom and activities of any UK government. Moreover, monetary economics is the basis for control of the economy. Money dominates the discussion, the debate and the action.
The Vision and Neo-liberal economics
The big questions for me are these. If we do what I suggest, how does that affect Neo-liberal economics? Does this Vision work within that framework and theory?
My ideas and suggestions do not obviously form an alternative “ism” like Keynesianism or mercantilism. They don’t have that coherence. But nor do they obviously upend Neo-liberal economics, nor Keynes’ ideas either, for that matter. They are much more Marks and Spencer, mix and match.
To my mind also, there is great appeal and sense in seeing the market as the starting point for an economy and for economics. After all, there were no economists around when, millennia ago, we started in business: trading in cattle and wives, or in almonds or corn. There were also no governments then, even though there probably have always been warlords. Government in any coherent sense emerged by around 3 or 4000 BC. Later we traded with portable precious objects like jewellery and rings. Then we started living in cities (civilisation), and that’s when government became necessary. The market became a physical place in the city and we traded in the market using gold and silver and copper and then the Chinese used paper, then dots on a computer screen and now invisible electrons moving so fast you can’t see them —pasteurised money—-past your eyes so fast……
With civilisation, living in cities, the public sector took an interest in business—and we all looked to the public sector for protection, law and order, weights and measures, a physical market place and some drains so it wasn’t too stinky. That’s when the forefathers of chaps like Keynes and Hayek began to get agitated. And now, here we are.
As I am not an economist I cannot in any case suggest an alternative to neoliberal economics. But clearly, my suggestions make certain quite radical changes to how it works. I will now outline them.
The first is more investment.
This seems to be in accord with any economic theory. But the proposals here have great difficulty for Neo-liberal economics as investment is now to be partially directed, persuaded, shaped by leaders—quite possibly political leaders in the public sector—instead of being a voluntary matter for the market. And more investment will only happen if the public and private sectors have similar ideas and, most importantly act similarly, in the same direction and speed. That does demand partnership, which is much more achievable if they share common goals.
However, there is no such thing as an investment or other business choice that is decided by the market alone. Henry Ford’s dictum that, “You can have any colour so long as it is black,” is of that kind: whilst it has its market logic, it is by no means clear that it was in the long term market interests of Ford. Indeed Alfred P. Sloan at General Motors later demonstrated otherwise.
What I am saying is that in any given time or situation, firms will come to market decisions that are not dictated, maybe never be dictated wholly by some market logic And when we consider investment and, I believe, the last 150 years of underinvesting in the UK, then the market, free or constrained, has signally failed to deliver. Has there been something wrong with the market all this time? Or is it a failure of business to take advantage of the market?
High Tech has been the main market driver, in my view, since 1700. I have emphasised this in Strategy 5. So why has high tech not driven the UK market since the end of the 19th century? Even Robert Stephenson’s famous engineering firm failed then, for lack of innovation and investment.
Surely, in the last 50 years, high tech has not been crowded out by financial services? Now there’s thought! And also crowded out by easy-peasy public contracts for those things that can easily be contracted out by the public sector? Low risk private sector investment with a captive public sector market?
That is certainly not the type of public-private partnership that I envisage. Certainly not PFI, nor contractors in a long term mission to destroy the grass verge outside our house and along our road—a mission now fully accomplished, though they have been recently and ably helped by high tech trenches dug barbarously. I envisage partnership where the state provides security, health, education and infrastructure, and the private sector works the market—but they work in a joint mission with a joint vision.
The most successful large economy at the moment is the Chinese. Here Indeed, common goals and equal determination between private and public sectors are what drives China and its economy. Yet China is indeed a market economy—albeit with public sector controls that we do not accept here. But which we may have to embrace in part, if we are to unite public and private and turn the UK economy around.
Investment in the real economy
Here, the ideas in this paper become much more intrusive into the market. What I am proposing is that investment is made into the real economy, not into most financial services. Marianna Mazzucato says that 80% of investment finance in the UK is going into financial services. She and Adam Smith agree that much, and too much of this, is parasitical, merely transferring value rather than creating it. They would wish to see that radically changed. Yes, Adam Smith, Marianna Mazzucato and I are agreed on this. No crowding out by financial services—nor sabotaging going concerns by loading them with debt!
Indeed, it seems that any sort of business, from water companies to homes for the elderly, can be turned into a financial asset in which the owner is only interested in money. In many instances he has no idea where some operating units are located. He lives in the Bahamas and maybe never visits. All he is interested in is return on capital and avoiding taxation. He is not interested in water, even less in water supply and even less in people being able to drink. He is not interested in old age or residents’ care. Even less is he interested in the staff he employs. And it is clear he even has little interest in other shareholders either.
Driving up wages
This is an outrageous demand on the private sector! But it is what economic growth is all about: driving up real wages. If real wages do not increase, then the whole purpose of economic growth is lost: there is no growth in the standard of living. If real wages do not increase, then no-one can buy the extra goodies produced by growing private businesses.
Years ago by chance, I met a Hong Kong businessman having coffee and listened with him to a lunchtime opera singer at Covent Garden market. He was complaining at how hard it was to do business then in Hong Kong, as wages kept rising. I explained, probably unsuccessfully, that that was the whole purpose of private enterprise!
Increasing wages is also culturally an impossible ask after 50 years of obsessive cost-cutting in both the private and public sectors—including cutting wages. But cutting the wage-bill by reducing working hours (usually with machines) is not the same as simply reducing workers’ pay or conditions—though the effect on the wage-bill is the same. Reducing wages and conditions by cutting the wage bill, simply reduces real wages and the ability of workers to buy the goods of the enterprise.
Nonetheless, increasing wages needs to be a shared goal if the economy is to grow and standards of living are to increase. One way is to couple it to a government programme to reduce benefits and taxation over the same period. Another way would be through parallel investment which is generally regarded as a route to increasing productivity.
But it clearly requires both the public and private sectors to work the market in a way that laissez-faire economics, Neo-liberal economics would not.
Redeploying labour
This again requires shared goals and partnership with the private sector. But it makes even greater demands as it requires the closing down of certain types of businesses or at least a change in their business model or even market sector. Without this, there will be no freeing up of labour and redeployment to value-adding activity.
It seems that this will only be achieved by government action: regulation, taxation, subsidy, skills training, publicity and persuasion. Without corporate, community action, individual firms will not and cannot be expected to unilaterally make radical changes to their business model. No firm can be expected to change important policies or activities unless it can be assured that rivals and the market will both change in the same direction and speed. No firm can go it alone, unless it is a near monopoly.
Diverting investment to a particular region or other locality also requires some strong action on the part of government, as well as achieving shared goals with the private sector. The planning process will be a major means of doing this. Public infrastructure investment is key, including house building, until such time as incomes are sufficient for all households to afford to pay for the roof over their head.
Dismantling the current housing rental market model
This is dramatic government intervention. It clearly is quite contrary to any laissez-faire market theory. But it is very limited in its scope—it only part of the housing market and only part of the property market. It has to be done.
But it does raise wider questions in my mind about the commercial market, particularly the retail property market and maybe office market. Is this being equally abused? Is this a major contributor to decline of the high street —and let’s not forget Councils’ commercial rates are determined by this. Rates simply add to shopkeepers’ rental woes.
The housing market as a whole and family savings
The proposals here strengthen the market. They remove a big chunk of public interference and intervention from the private sector. They release the shackles. And they move a big chunk of public activity and spending into the market. Rejoice ye marketeers! Again, I say, rejoice!
Restraint in the south and enterprise elsewhere
What could be more balanced than that? Even better, as it couples this to expenditure on climate change, giving investment opportunities and driving economic growth and creating a richer nation able to buy more private sector goodies.
Monetary economics
This is separate from Neo-liberal economics. I guess it is a way of managing a lot of different economies operating under various economic theories. Managing the economy through controlling the money supply, inflation and interest rates seems and has proved to be a good method.
But it is part of the obsession with money which dominates British thinking to the exclusion of real resources. It raises such questions as, “Does the Bank of England control the money markets or do the money markets control the Bank of England?” I do not have the expertise to answer this question. But it in turn raises the question, “Is the Government’s management of the economy dominated by money considerations?” And if so, then whose considerations are they dominated by: the government’s or the market’s?
Where does this leave Neo-liberal economics ?
Like the curate’s egg, these strategies, this vision, is good in part for the market, for the private sector. But it does restrict and change some parts of the market. Nonetheless, I believe it is good overall—very good and will or could turn the economy and Britain round.
Consequently, the proposals here do not obviously over-turn Neo-liberal economics. But they certainly modify them by substantial government and public/private partnership interventions. Yet the bedrock is still the market and its freedom to operate, but in a more restricted world. Economists must decide whether or not this is still Neo-liberal economics! Crucially, as I said in the first strategy of all, they also need to advise on whether or not it will work at all—whatever economic theory it represents!
The Vision Re-cast
Here, then, are 10 strategies for turning Britain around. They don’t cover everything. For instance, we also need to tackle corruption and failures and abuses of IT, not to mention trade etc with Europe. But there are enough strategies here, and they form some cohesive whole. And that is absolutely crucial. Crucially, they are tackled together, one supporting the other, one only possible because of another, achieving more than the sum of the parts. This is new. It replaces attempts to tackle each of the policy areas individually, which is what we have been doing for years. Not just in silo government but also in silo politics. And silo thinking around the country. Unified, they yield big opportunities to achieve our aims.
1 Economic modelling of this proposed programme
2 A 20 year programme of redeploying wasted resources
3 Responding to climate change and tackling plastics
4 Establish a North/South divide and Southern restraint policy
5 Private sector investment
6 A 20 year programme of raising wages and incomes
7 A 20 year programme of reducing benefits
8 A 20 year programme to create a society where food and housing are paid from the income of each person and family, and pensions and social care in old age are paid from their savings
9 Public sector investment and day to day spending
10 Continuing to promote high tech etc
The Opportunities
A serendipitous opportunity to combine and greatly increase our efforts on climate change, the north south divide and economic growth. Three for the price of three. Now that’s a real bargain!
Opportunity to tackle low wages and reduce the welfare bill and taxation in one policy.
Maintaining the state pension as foundation and backstop.
Opportunity to take housing for ordinary people out of the public sector, by recognising our high western standard of living and wealth and taking steps to use it more wisely.
Opportunity to give greater control of their lives to middle and lower income families by making them less dependent on the state, and for the richer sort, by somewhat reducing taxation .
Opportunity to somewhat reduce the size of the public sector.
Opportunity to find resources for the key services of the state, which drive and support economic growth: particularly Education, the NHS and infrastructure.
A national opportunity to unite behind a vision which will benefit most of us—any action has costs to some people.
An opportunity to unite people in a national project, not divide people, as Brexit and the contagion of Trump divides.
The Achievement
A people, most of whom can feed themselves and provide a roof over their heads without state or charitable help, and can save for pensions and for social care, if needed in old age.
A reduced welfare bill and tax burden.
Resources to aid those who cannot feed or house themselves.
Resources to help the unemployed find work, for those becoming redundant, and for those not in education and training, who only stand and wait.
A million or so workers freed from valueless labour or idleness to become contributors to our community —from wasted lives to valued and satisfying lives.
Resources to clean rivers, fight climate change, repair our roads (not fill pot-holes), and to repair broken Britain.
Resources freed to enable investment by the private and public sectors.
An economy such as the Blessed Margaret envisaged, where most families can support themselves. But in addition, an economy where we can pay the state to provide for us communally, and where we can deliver on the West’s responsibility and debt to the rest of the world for the damage we have wittingly and unwittingly done.
Achievable aims, achieved in partnership, not division, and with optimism, not pessimism. But hard toil for 20 years or more.
Then hopefully, the trees will smile again, as we repair their world; and even the Almighty will feel he can have another sabbath day of rest!
And still more: with reinvented NHS dentistry and good teeth, we will be able ourselves to smile broadly again!
© Philip Morgan 2026 Public Policy Conjectures All rights reserved.
Leave a Reply